Easter is in just a few short weeks and if you haven’t already planned what to fill those Easter baskets with, I’m here to help! Today I’m sharing a roundup of some of my favorite Easter Basket Stuffers for Toddlers.
Be sure to download my free printable Easter Planner at the bottom of the post too!
Orginially published March 2021. Updated March 2023
This year for Easter we’re getting together at my mom’s house. My son James and his wife and little Aiden will be coming too and I can’t wait to see them! Aiden is the cutest little toddler ever. He’s such a happy boy!
It can be difficult to know what to put in your toddler’s Easter basket if you aren’t sure where to start. I recommend using safe and environmentally friendly grass like paper shreds. Remember to watch your little one closely!
I’m excited to share these fun ideas for Easter basket stuffers toddlers will love. I’ve included different things from board books to puzzles, musical shakers to soft plush toys, and more!
Faith-Based Ideas for Making Easter Special: Video
20 Easter Basket Stuffers for Toddlers
- Jesus loves Me board book.
- 6 tabbed board pages. Each tab has a recognizable song for your little one to sing
- Perfect gift to give at a christening, baptism, first communion, Easter and more!
- Introduce your little one to Jesus at an early age
- Marshmallow Zoo Junior Lamb is an ultra-soft friend with a textured fabric body with a wooly look that feels super soft.
- Incredibly huggable, little arms will love to squeeze; machine washable in cold water on gentle cycle, air dry.
A gentle look at Jesus's birth, childhood, teachings, crucifixion, and resurrection. Written in a simple, warm style, with colorful illustrations that will captivate and inspire.
Egg Shakers are ideal Musical Instruments for children, easy to play and master. Can develop kids' musical skills, strengthen their fine-motor muscles, improve their color recognition and enhance their eye-hand coordination.
This sweet and brightly colored board book explores the presence of Jesus in our lives. If Jesus lived inside our hearts, would it show in our daily actions? This delightful little story explores just that as the toddlers in the story learn to be kind and generous in a variety of situations.
Wooden lacing & Tracing Cards threading toys Includes 5 wooden animals cards and 5 laces, Sturdy wooden construction with non-toxic.
- Contains sweet, rhymed text, perfect for reading aloud and savoring at home
- Features adorable animal illustrations that children will love
- Has a simple, heartwarming message ideal for children ages 0-4
- Helps toddlers develop fine motor skills, cognitive skills, hand eye coordination, problem solving
- Easy glide zipper pocket; Decorated with numbers and shapes will engage child to learn early math and counting
- Playful bright plush with vibrant colored straps, and buckles to hold child's attention
Noah's Ark Toys for Toddlers Wooden Animal Shape Sorter Toys
Noahs Ark Toy - Noahs ark playset includes 2 lions, 2 crocodiles, 2 rhinoceros, 2 zebras, 2 giraffes, 2 elephants, 2 doves, storybook, rainbow, ark, Noah and his wife. Noah ark wooden toy will bring endless fun to your children and stimulate their imagination!
This simple and adorable kids fishing game offers hours of fun for children ages 3+ and comes with an “underwater” game board, 12 little fish, and 2 magnetic fishing poles. How fast can you hook a catch?
- Made of natural wood, each piece is chunky and solid, durable enough to use over and over again.
- 51 large pieces floor puzzle is easy to hold and put together for 3-5, 4-8 boy and girl children.
6 Packs brain-building jigsaw puzzles-cute animals: bear, butterfly, ladybug, car, bee, and tortoise can help toddlers to improve create concentration and solve puzzles capacities. It can also develop a toddler's colors, patience, imagination, and hand-eye coordination.
The Melissa & Doug Paint with Water Activity Books Set is a three-pack water-coloring book for kids featuring jungle, barn animals, and underwater ocean scenes and a paint palette embedded right inside the book. Makes a delightful and educational gift for kids from 3 to 6 years.
Beautifully packaged keepsake gift that includes a watercolor illustrated board book about prayer and a “Pray with Me” plush bunny that recites “Now I Lay Me Down to Sleep” in a sweet little girl’s voice when you press her tummy.
'Twas the Night Before Easter It’s Easter time in Crisper County and cable news reporter Marlee Meade (Petunia Rhubarb) is hunting for a way to help others.
- The anti-roll shape keeps sticks handy without rolling away and produces fine lines or broad strokes that simply wash away with water. As with any Crayola Sidewalk Chalk, your designs are completely washable and come off with a garden hose or the next rainy day!
Enjoy time together with your baby or toddler by thanking God for all the wonderful animals in the world with this adorable lift-a-flap book. Follow along in the story and look for who made cats, frogs, butterflies, giraffes, and more.
12 charming eggs in a carton will help preschoolers learn to count, sort, and match! Each plastic egg contains a different color and number, with corresponding pegs and holes.
Follow along with the beautiful rainbow puppet and look around to see all the colors and creatures God made. This adorable story about love and faith features a fun finger puppet toy built into the board book, encouraging interactive play.
- Sorting Game: Your baby will need to recognize the size of carrots to put them back to the slot.
- Developmental Benefits: While playing with this wooden toy, your little one is also developing fine motor skill, hand-eye coordination, shape recognition and dexterity.
What can I fill plastic Easter Eggs with for Toddlers?
It’s important that anything small not pose a choking hazard, but always watch your toddler closely! I’ve always been super paranoid about kids choking and still remember every single time one of my five kids choked on something. It’s so scary!
Some safe ideas for filling those plastic Easter Eggs for your toddlers are:
- animal crackers
- peanut butter crackers
- chocolate bunnies
- toddler snack packs
What are you planning to put in your toddler’s Easter basket this year?
More Easter Ideas You’ll Love
- How to Teach Children the Easter Story + Printable Story Cards
- Christian Easter Basket Stuffers for Kids
- Easy Empty Tomb Rolls | Resurrection Rolls for Easter
Free Printable Easter Planner
How to Download
- Just fill out the form below and you’ll receive an email giving you instant access to my free printable Easter Planner.
- If you are already a subscriber, filling out the form won’t affect your subscription, but you will receive the link to download!
Why should I subscribe?
- access to my subscriber exclusive resource library
- exclusive coupons and sales to my shop
- updates, challenges, freebies, and exclusive offers
- instant access to subscriber exclusive printables